«
»

Clarification: What sucks and what don’t

04.23.05 | 4 Comments

ono.gifSean of Ministrare is right.  Something is happening in UU circles.  I don’t want to overplay it, but the UU blogosphere abounds in discussions of what our "unity amid diversity" might be.  (See Chalice Chick’s review for links.) The new UU Theology listserv is aimed directly at the issue.  And Sean reports movements along the same in the UU bureaucracy.

The natural starting points for this discussion are UUism’s "Purposes & Principles."   Chalice Chick points out that I’m arguing that—contrary to the usual quips—the P&P don’t suck.  Sean points out that that I’m only "timidly defending" the P&P.  So what exactly am I saying?

1) Let’s start with what I’m not saying.   I’m not saying the P&P are "pie in the sky by and by."  Their lack of poetry reveals their bureaucratic origin, and I am naturally predisposed to dismiss anything that comes from a bureaucracy.  (Trying to put that as politely as I can.)  They can be improved, and they should be periodically.

I’m also not saying they should function as a creed (more on that below).  Not even that they are good enough to do so if we wished.  So set your panic buttons to off.

2)  Now to what I am saying.   

In spite of their bureaucratic origins, the P&P still contain some genuine theological poetry.  Not a lot, but enough to warrant some respect.  I attribute this happy coincidence (of poetry with bureaucracy) to grace.  Why?

At UUCA we have a growing group for twenty- and thirtysomethings.  Almost everyone in this loose knit group of 100+ folks is new to UUism.  Most are single, although there is a sizable minority of married/partnered folks, some with young children.

I have been amazed that a good number (eight or twelve) of the forty or fifty folks in the group who I’ve met have said that reading the P&P (online, usually) was central to their decision to come and get involved.  The proportion was similar in my new member class five years ago.  Don’t look that gift horse in the mouth. 

This was my experience too.  The P&P told me that UUs weren’t the "knock on the door with nothing to say," nor were UUs putting on a circle jerk to worn photos of Carl Sagan, Carl Rogers, and Bertrand Russell.   I saw enough of that in high school, thanks.  I saw something in the P&P that spoke to a larger vision.

Why then are the P&P so maligned?  First, because of an irrational fear of creeds (almost to that below).  Second, because familiarity breeds contempt. 

Third, because so many UUs seem to think that every [good American, rational person, etc.] already agrees with the P&P.  If you think that, I challenge you to ask the next ten nonUUs you meet outside of Harvard Square if the P&P describe what they believe.  More will say no than yes.  Otherwise, things like this wouldn’t be happening at such an increasing frequency.

3)  Finally, some things I haven’t said before/yet.  Our "creed phobia" has to stop.  I fully realize and appreciate that there are good historical reasons we do not have a creed.  I don’t want a "creed" myself.

But as Paul Wilczynski points out, the P&P practically function as a creed.   Yet many of us (myself, sometimes) exhibit what looks to me like terror at the thought.  That can’t be healthy, and it can’t help but send a crazy message to others. Especially to would-be UUs, or at least the ones who don’t share that terror.  (And my experience teaches me that pre-terrified proto-UUs are the vast minority.") "Creed terror" does’t have anything to do with those good historical reasons for not having a creed, because if it did it wouldn’t exhibit as terror.  I won’t venture to say what’s causing this creed terror, but I’ll suggest the cure lies in spending some time in what my Pentecostal neighbor would call your "personal prayer closet."

Those folks at UUCA who came because of the P&P weren’t looking for a "creed," by the way.  They weren’t looking for someone to tell them what they should believe, so you can put that insulting diatribe aside now.  They wondered what we stood for, and the P&P gave them a good idea. 

Is that wrong?  Is that harmful in any way?  Is there any justification for chastising them as "ye of little faith" because they found the P&P helpful, or even comforting? 

I challenge anyone who feels otherwise to answer me with a non-elitist argument that honors the experience of our fellow UUs who have experienced some small measure of grace throught the P&P.  I’m all for calling them the "Seven Dwarves," and I too wonder "where’s the beef?"  But they are still a gift of grace to UUism, and that’s nothing to balk at.

4 Comments

have your say

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. Subscribe to these comments.

Be colorful. Keep it fun. Stay on topic. No spam.

:  (required)

:  (required, not published)

 (wow! a link to my site!)


«
»
  • bula 10 mg
  • effets secondaires du
  • used staph infection
  • is an ace inhibitor
  • how to get pregnant with and
  • costco
  • vitamin b12 and
  • dental side effects
  • better
  • u dzieci dawkowanie
  • once a day
  • sam's club price
  • take
  • tabs
  • kids side effects
  • crema v
  • photos of patients
  • how to use cream for skin cancer
  • complications
  • anger issues
  • fda recall
  • cure
  • et l'Ajaculation precoce
  • kidney stones
  • and together
  • dosage
  • qt prolongation
  • for children with anxiety
  • bowel movements
  • or which one safer
  • co 80\/ 12.5 fiyatA
  • does cause weight gain
  • can make you ovulate early
  • 150 mg patient savings card
  • for fever
  • affect cycle length
  • for children safety
  • drug
  • for sale online australia
  • compare and proair
  • klonopin
  • long shelf life
  • peak concentration
  • side effects webmd
  • does cause weight gain
  • weaning schedule
  • happens if stop taking my
  • hfa use
  • toxicity mri
  • recreationally
  • pregnancy birth defects
  • ds used for std
  • should i take for food poisoning
  • works quickly
  • septic tank motor
  • side effects bloating
  • odblokowanie meta
  • is a barbiturate
  • compare and
  • blood pressure medication dosage
  • side effects children
  • schmerzgel 150 g preise
  • where to buy
  • side effects hearing loss
  • addiction
  • z pak
  • difference entre and
  • bad dreams
  • pediatric package insert
  • generic
  • class
  • for labial adhesions
  • pfizer brazil
  • dosing
  • 2mg
  • what is the next step if doesn't work
  • moa
  • dosage how to take
  • side effects in women
  • how long does take to work
  • side effects of hct 20mg 12.5mg
  • dairy
  • pastillas sirven para abortar aparte
  • stomach upset
  • hydrochloride
  • take and at the same time
  • ad
  • price canada
  • sulfa
  • vs anxiety
  • purchase
  • what is ds tablets used for
  • cycle day 3
  • flexeril interactions
  • compare
  • long your system
  • can you take
  • e infartuati
  • side effects in children under 5
  • tremors while taking
  • use of for premature ejaculation
  • safe take benadryl after taking
  • 5-9 or 3-7
  • and alcohol use
  • 10 mg
  • can drink alcohol
  • probability getting pregnant taking
  • que es el
  • para que sirve el medicamento
  • cifra da musica me cifra club
  • low dose and weight gain
  • for ulcer treatment
  • vs pct
  • rebound heart attacks
  • billig
  • reactions babies
  • relenza pregnant women
  • took 2 by accident
  • side effects long term use
  • 32 side effects
  • cancer rats
  • v relpax
  • iv
  • 1 gm tablet
  • 100mg o que e
  • quoi sert
  • skin cancer
  • d sore throat
  • uses medication
  • pollock and
  • use of in children
  • safe take
  • treatment duration
  • water retention
  • buy online
  • average dosage
  • can treat yeast infection
  • google
  • and high potassium levels
  • posologie
  • is a statin
  • restless legs
  • family
  • vs infant reflux
  • interaction
  • ente nazionale del turismo di
  • presbyterian clinic albuquerque nm
  • tolerance
  • pastillas abortivas ecuador
  • bronchitis dosage
  • 25 mg 30 tablet
  • prescribing info
  • vs
  • wellbutrin weight loss
  • interactions
  • ds used treat sinus infections
  • how much does generic cost without insurance
  • 28 for acne
  • como tirar o
  • of
  • side effects together
  • combination side effects
  • can you take tylenol pregnant
  • evaluate effectiveness
  • add
  • q10 enzyme
  • for mirena
  • for pertussis exposure
  • medication information
  • can klonopin help with withdrawal
  • gia thuoc 75mg
  • high blood pressure
  • bula do 0 5 mg
  • para que es 50 mg
  • what happens if you just stop taking
  • dosage herpes simplex 1
  • fast heart rate
  • off label use
  • ds route of administration
  • permet il l'ovulation
  • plus advil
  • 2 weeks
  • cheapest online
  • i am allergic to penicillin can i take
  • difference between
  • is used for bipolar disorder
  • half weight gain
  • can affect birth control
  • do kiedy braA w ciAA?y
  • 400 mg 80 mg dawkowanie
  • how long do you take for toenail fungus
  • gsk coupon
  • cheap pills
  • processing speed
  • what is 500mg used for
  • do need prescription
  • ok take same time
  • take at night or morning
  • lek za prostatu
  • schering plough
  • cream australia
  • and liver
  • zegerid otc
  • maximum effectiveness time
  • side effects infants
  • nauseas despues tomar
  • pill pictures
  • use cataract surgery
  • spanish
  • will raise blood pressure
  • jarabe pediatrico argentina
  • otc tablet picture
  • twins success stories
  • mpf ingredients
  • capsules 6mg
  • za kosu
  • dosage strengths
  • does cream work for ringworm
  • dosage 3 year old
  • low dose
  • why not use on genital herpes
  • how long until works
  • how quickly does work for babies
  • warning label
  • e nausea
  • tinnitus
  • issues
  • and dosage
  • treat tooth infection
  • price rite aid
  • can cause depression
  • can i take ambien and together
  • is good for bipolar disorder
  • w niemczech bez recepty
  • edad recomendable
  • vs
  • can i take 2 a day
  • keeps me awake
  • korkunA film 4
  • used uti
  • in postpartum hemorrhage
  • good substitute
  • buy d 24 hour
  • can you od
  • e il sole
  • can help ovulation
  • a calcica 20 mg
  • central sleep apnea
  • history twins
  • children yeast
  • for chest infection
  • broad spectrum antibiotic
  • 10mg vs 20mg
  • price of d
  • does cause liver damage
  • women urinary retention
  • can you buy in spain
  • side effects
  • interaction
  • low dose
  • e zerinol
  • 1 beer
  • vomiting blood
  • que es el medicamento
  • class action lawsuit against
  • is safe for hot flashes
  • does show up on drug test
  • cream substitute
  • cognitive side effects
  • 3 times a day
  • where to buy in uk
  • and skin rash
  • ir package insert
  • taking for 3 years
  • for depression and anxiety
  • false negative pregnancy test after
  • how to use
  • taken
  • causing yeast infection
  • auxiliary labels
  • para que serve
  • can you take nyquil and together
  • hypertension arterielle
  • numbness
  • buy online with prescription
  • how many milligrams of for morning sickness
  • ppi guidelines
  • tablets and alcohol
  • cns damage
  • can you take more than once a day
  • bacterial resistance
  • india
  • assistance program form
  • keramag plan 1 unterschrank
  • does cause false positive
  • good constipation
  • taking after 40
  • prehospital administration
  • why can't you eat cranberries on
  • can you take d with prozac
  • will treat kidney infection
  • maximum dosage per day
  • mood swings
  • drug interactions ambien
  • 25 mcg cost
  • 10 years
  • 608782944
  • for plants fertilizer
  • or
  • blisters
  • how much does cost without insurance
  • for eps
  • 2 mg price
  • side effects acid reflux
  • or . trilipix
  • glass hollander
  • hypothyroidism infertility
  • how long does stay in system
  • lyrica together
  • difference between and aspirin
  • combo
  • dose for sleep
  • y repentil
  • price
  • vomiting after taking
  • and dosage
  • cost mexico
  • does cause weight gain
  • first trimester
  • better than
  • vs comparison
  • acne reviews
  • are benadryl and the same thing
  • get high
  • for h1n1 virus
  • first two weeks
  • musica gospel minha vida me chama pelo nome
  • for chest infection
  • emulgel for plantar fasciitis
  • treats acne
  • many years take
  • taking and
  • drinking alcohol after taking
  • dosing for infant gerd
  • and hydrocodone together
  • vs efudex
  • order online
  • bipolar
  • statdose prescribing information
  • how long do you take for uti
  • and alcohol consumption
  • phentermine taken
  • use in hospitals
  • for bipolar ii
  • heart problems
  • en de bijwerkingen
  • can you take to get high
  • tested animals
  • dangers stopping cold turkey
  • itching
  • kremi nedir
  • sleep
  • pfizer $4 coupon
  • allergy med
  • potassium
  • nerve pain medicine
  • side effects
  • interaction between tylenol
  • heart problems
  • yellow pill 10
  • is safe
  • dry mouth
  • tan riesgoso aborto
  • 8 year old
  • synulox o
  • y colesterol
  • interaction of with alcohol
  • feel worse before better
  • benefits of for children
  • causes weight gain
  • raise blood sugar
  • treatment uti
  • rash children
  • cheap pills uk
  • para que es la pastilla
  • vs hair loss
  • and liver enzymes elevations
  • consta manufacturer
  • farmacocinAtica do
  • 75 mg capsule
  • chills
  • side effects percentage
  • does regrow hairline
  • bleeding while on
  • msd 60 mg
  • can you take vicodin together
  • flushing
  • medication side effects
  • shortness of breath
  • interactions