Clarification: What sucks and what don’t

04.23.05 | 4 Comments

ono.gifSean of Ministrare is right.  Something is happening in UU circles.  I don’t want to overplay it, but the UU blogosphere abounds in discussions of what our "unity amid diversity" might be.  (See Chalice Chick’s review for links.) The new UU Theology listserv is aimed directly at the issue.  And Sean reports movements along the same in the UU bureaucracy.

The natural starting points for this discussion are UUism’s "Purposes & Principles."   Chalice Chick points out that I’m arguing that—contrary to the usual quips—the P&P don’t suck.  Sean points out that that I’m only "timidly defending" the P&P.  So what exactly am I saying?

1) Let’s start with what I’m not saying.   I’m not saying the P&P are "pie in the sky by and by."  Their lack of poetry reveals their bureaucratic origin, and I am naturally predisposed to dismiss anything that comes from a bureaucracy.  (Trying to put that as politely as I can.)  They can be improved, and they should be periodically.

I’m also not saying they should function as a creed (more on that below).  Not even that they are good enough to do so if we wished.  So set your panic buttons to off.

2)  Now to what I am saying.   

In spite of their bureaucratic origins, the P&P still contain some genuine theological poetry.  Not a lot, but enough to warrant some respect.  I attribute this happy coincidence (of poetry with bureaucracy) to grace.  Why?

At UUCA we have a growing group for twenty- and thirtysomethings.  Almost everyone in this loose knit group of 100+ folks is new to UUism.  Most are single, although there is a sizable minority of married/partnered folks, some with young children.

I have been amazed that a good number (eight or twelve) of the forty or fifty folks in the group who I’ve met have said that reading the P&P (online, usually) was central to their decision to come and get involved.  The proportion was similar in my new member class five years ago.  Don’t look that gift horse in the mouth. 

This was my experience too.  The P&P told me that UUs weren’t the "knock on the door with nothing to say," nor were UUs putting on a circle jerk to worn photos of Carl Sagan, Carl Rogers, and Bertrand Russell.   I saw enough of that in high school, thanks.  I saw something in the P&P that spoke to a larger vision.

Why then are the P&P so maligned?  First, because of an irrational fear of creeds (almost to that below).  Second, because familiarity breeds contempt. 

Third, because so many UUs seem to think that every [good American, rational person, etc.] already agrees with the P&P.  If you think that, I challenge you to ask the next ten nonUUs you meet outside of Harvard Square if the P&P describe what they believe.  More will say no than yes.  Otherwise, things like this wouldn’t be happening at such an increasing frequency.

3)  Finally, some things I haven’t said before/yet.  Our "creed phobia" has to stop.  I fully realize and appreciate that there are good historical reasons we do not have a creed.  I don’t want a "creed" myself.

But as Paul Wilczynski points out, the P&P practically function as a creed.   Yet many of us (myself, sometimes) exhibit what looks to me like terror at the thought.  That can’t be healthy, and it can’t help but send a crazy message to others. Especially to would-be UUs, or at least the ones who don’t share that terror.  (And my experience teaches me that pre-terrified proto-UUs are the vast minority.") "Creed terror" does’t have anything to do with those good historical reasons for not having a creed, because if it did it wouldn’t exhibit as terror.  I won’t venture to say what’s causing this creed terror, but I’ll suggest the cure lies in spending some time in what my Pentecostal neighbor would call your "personal prayer closet."

Those folks at UUCA who came because of the P&P weren’t looking for a "creed," by the way.  They weren’t looking for someone to tell them what they should believe, so you can put that insulting diatribe aside now.  They wondered what we stood for, and the P&P gave them a good idea. 

Is that wrong?  Is that harmful in any way?  Is there any justification for chastising them as "ye of little faith" because they found the P&P helpful, or even comforting? 

I challenge anyone who feels otherwise to answer me with a non-elitist argument that honors the experience of our fellow UUs who have experienced some small measure of grace throught the P&P.  I’m all for calling them the "Seven Dwarves," and I too wonder "where’s the beef?"  But they are still a gift of grace to UUism, and that’s nothing to balk at.


have your say

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. Subscribe to these comments.

Be colorful. Keep it fun. Stay on topic. No spam.

:  (required)

:  (required, not published)

 (wow! a link to my site!)

  • breach 3 game download
  • bloodhound gang mope download mp3
  • cd sandro matos 2011 download
  • ben howard esmerelda download mp3
  • black book improvised munitions download
  • apostila prf 2009 download gratis
  • 22 kule download lektor pl
  • ai no tame ni download
  • 13th warrior download full movie
  • branca de neve musicas download
  • canon mp250 download windows
  • chattakkari movie song download
  • cavalieri dello zodiaco hd download
  • bus driver download original
  • adobe acrobat x pro download mac
  • call me mp3 download blondie
  • bizhub c300 driver download
  • billie jean dj zet download
  • badla movie songs download
  • acerto de contas download
  • ali haider nohay download mp3
  • bot pwbr genesis download
  • ben howard esmerelda download mp3
  • canon canoscan 8800f software download
  • animatrix download dual audio
  • aventail download for mac
  • arvo part symphony no 4 download
  • cadillacs e dinossauros ps2 download
  • bumper ball game download free
  • acer 5315 drivers download
  • alkitab elektronik indonesia download
  • acrobat x pro download baixaki
  • 20 20 kitchen design software download
  • 3com 3c905b tx download driver windows 7
  • bons jogos de tiro download
  • a killing art tahun download
  • clubbed 2 death botdf download
  • britannica 2011 ultimate download
  • baixedetudo net download dragon ball
  • aplikacja google play download
  • book mormon soundtrack download
  • clarice falcA?o download do cd
  • cat de departe holograf download fisierul meu
  • banquete de amor download legendado
  • calice chico buarque download mp3
  • a2sd froyo root apk download
  • cd super dragoes 2011 download
  • axinte album 2012 download
  • best worst movie download
  • canon handycam driver download
  • blackout tek one remix download
  • animal crossing wild world pc download kostenlos
  • battleship 2012 download mkv
  • bugs bunny fun house download
  • aviso de tempestade download dublado
  • arang and the magistrate download blogspot
  • cabana livro download gratis
  • boomshakalaka nba jam sound download
  • casimiro de abreu poemas download
  • bade chete aunde ne download song
  • ang aking awitin mp3 download
  • aspire 7520 acer download
  • aifam jaraj sie download mp3
  • bleach episode 271 hd download
  • canopus hq codec download windows
  • canon pixma mx850 treiber download
  • bully download for mac
  • car brake mp3 download
  • almighty glory kid cudi download
  • cisco ios download for 3560
  • angie aparo silent night download
  • cad software 2012 download
  • almanaque das sociedades secretas download sabra
  • adele new orleans bounce download
  • a v s video editor download
  • clara nunes download mp3 gratis
  • 4.04 galaxy s2 download
  • audio book download for iphone
  • aku orang miskin mp3 download
  • chite suit te daag download mp3
  • canon mp550 driver download free
  • burned up the night download free
  • bodo sti de ce download zippy
  • bleach cap 446 download ita
  • 10 class papers download
  • beatriz download vocA? A uma benAA?o
  • bhadra movie download links
  • a l past papers download
  • ant smasher free download pc