Clarification: What sucks and what don’t

04.23.05 | 4 Comments

ono.gifSean of Ministrare is right.  Something is happening in UU circles.  I don’t want to overplay it, but the UU blogosphere abounds in discussions of what our "unity amid diversity" might be.  (See Chalice Chick’s review for links.) The new UU Theology listserv is aimed directly at the issue.  And Sean reports movements along the same in the UU bureaucracy.

The natural starting points for this discussion are UUism’s "Purposes & Principles."   Chalice Chick points out that I’m arguing that—contrary to the usual quips—the P&P don’t suck.  Sean points out that that I’m only "timidly defending" the P&P.  So what exactly am I saying?

1) Let’s start with what I’m not saying.   I’m not saying the P&P are "pie in the sky by and by."  Their lack of poetry reveals their bureaucratic origin, and I am naturally predisposed to dismiss anything that comes from a bureaucracy.  (Trying to put that as politely as I can.)  They can be improved, and they should be periodically.

I’m also not saying they should function as a creed (more on that below).  Not even that they are good enough to do so if we wished.  So set your panic buttons to off.

2)  Now to what I am saying.   

In spite of their bureaucratic origins, the P&P still contain some genuine theological poetry.  Not a lot, but enough to warrant some respect.  I attribute this happy coincidence (of poetry with bureaucracy) to grace.  Why?

At UUCA we have a growing group for twenty- and thirtysomethings.  Almost everyone in this loose knit group of 100+ folks is new to UUism.  Most are single, although there is a sizable minority of married/partnered folks, some with young children.

I have been amazed that a good number (eight or twelve) of the forty or fifty folks in the group who I’ve met have said that reading the P&P (online, usually) was central to their decision to come and get involved.  The proportion was similar in my new member class five years ago.  Don’t look that gift horse in the mouth. 

This was my experience too.  The P&P told me that UUs weren’t the "knock on the door with nothing to say," nor were UUs putting on a circle jerk to worn photos of Carl Sagan, Carl Rogers, and Bertrand Russell.   I saw enough of that in high school, thanks.  I saw something in the P&P that spoke to a larger vision.

Why then are the P&P so maligned?  First, because of an irrational fear of creeds (almost to that below).  Second, because familiarity breeds contempt. 

Third, because so many UUs seem to think that every [good American, rational person, etc.] already agrees with the P&P.  If you think that, I challenge you to ask the next ten nonUUs you meet outside of Harvard Square if the P&P describe what they believe.  More will say no than yes.  Otherwise, things like this wouldn’t be happening at such an increasing frequency.

3)  Finally, some things I haven’t said before/yet.  Our "creed phobia" has to stop.  I fully realize and appreciate that there are good historical reasons we do not have a creed.  I don’t want a "creed" myself.

But as Paul Wilczynski points out, the P&P practically function as a creed.   Yet many of us (myself, sometimes) exhibit what looks to me like terror at the thought.  That can’t be healthy, and it can’t help but send a crazy message to others. Especially to would-be UUs, or at least the ones who don’t share that terror.  (And my experience teaches me that pre-terrified proto-UUs are the vast minority.") "Creed terror" does’t have anything to do with those good historical reasons for not having a creed, because if it did it wouldn’t exhibit as terror.  I won’t venture to say what’s causing this creed terror, but I’ll suggest the cure lies in spending some time in what my Pentecostal neighbor would call your "personal prayer closet."

Those folks at UUCA who came because of the P&P weren’t looking for a "creed," by the way.  They weren’t looking for someone to tell them what they should believe, so you can put that insulting diatribe aside now.  They wondered what we stood for, and the P&P gave them a good idea. 

Is that wrong?  Is that harmful in any way?  Is there any justification for chastising them as "ye of little faith" because they found the P&P helpful, or even comforting? 

I challenge anyone who feels otherwise to answer me with a non-elitist argument that honors the experience of our fellow UUs who have experienced some small measure of grace throught the P&P.  I’m all for calling them the "Seven Dwarves," and I too wonder "where’s the beef?"  But they are still a gift of grace to UUism, and that’s nothing to balk at.


have your say

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. Subscribe to these comments.

Be colorful. Keep it fun. Stay on topic. No spam.

:  (required)

:  (required, not published)

 (wow! a link to my site!)

  • do cd roupa nova perfil
  • red cafe we fly mp3
  • madonna take a bow instrumental
  • holi geet mp3 free download
  • lagu jkt48 aitakatta free
  • full version internet manager software
  • warcraft 3 download free full game pc
  • joe jonas songs free download mp3
  • tibia download para windows 7
  • hp deskjet 3050 software mac
  • typing tutor full version free 2012
  • closing ceremony paralympics 2012
  • imovie for pc download
  • descargas jdownloader musica
  • download live tv software for samsung wave y
  • stranded 2 multiplayer english download
  • fc barcelona theme song mp3
  • dvd noite e dia mp3
  • msn live download for vista
  • ios 5 gm download non developer
  • touch miss a mini album
  • garritan concert marching band 2 free download
  • download video song jugni tanu weds manu
  • msn download version 2011
  • fazendo meu filme 1 download gratis
  • scooby doo games download softonic
  • nero 6 with serial keys
  • ban hack zing speed
  • kanchana mina 2 mp3 songs free download
  • cisco packet tracer 5.3 download for mac
  • epson dx5050 driver download
  • download la batalla de la mente joyce meyer
  • download throwed off clean version
  • logitech quickcam communicate stx driver
  • hillsong his love mp3 download
  • no trial free games
  • nortel vpn client download windows 7
  • wear my hat mp3
  • lagu ungu dirimu diriku
  • atif aslam songs free download mp3 new
  • optima bold font free windows
  • microsoft c runtime library download
  • xem phim ngot ngao em yeu online
  • bound fun 2
  • si me u video prej youtubes
  • big games free download racing
  • do susanne download free
  • free lagu ruth sahanaya andaikan kau datang kembali
  • delia feat puya gone zippy
  • eclipse dublado avi gratis
  • meu malvado favorito dublado hd
  • coin generator for fifa 12 xbox
  • opera 11 download free for windows xp
  • cardcaptor sakura episodes english dubbed
  • imran series mazhar kaleem free download bartel format
  • super mario.iso psp
  • gta sa police car pack
  • stereo mix sound driver
  • robert kiyosaki business of the 21st century mp3 download
  • rockman exe download anime
  • pokemon theme song download full
  • come un pittore moda free mp3 download
  • cd download jorge e matheus 2011
  • exo wolf album free
  • penguin test your vocabulary 3
  • flux pavillion bass cannon zomboy zippy
  • love free download themes
  • jiya re mp3 djmaza
  • super mario crossover game free
  • paixA?o de cristo avi download
  • management pack scom 2007 r2
  • eurostile extended black dtc
  • saibo video song free download
  • download mp3 terbaru 2012 korea
  • badi mushkil hai song
  • quake 2 free pc
  • dvd eduardo costa ao vivo 2011
  • need for speed download demo
  • baixar desconhecido legendado rmvb
  • ijazat remix by falak mp3
  • dance big sean ft nicki minaj mp3
  • kele okereke everything you wanted mp3
  • download bukti potong pph 23
  • move your body download eiffel 65
  • windows mail for windows 7 free
  • tekken tag tournament 2 ps3 iso download
  • how to files off soundcloud
  • crash corrida download pc
  • free heartstrings subtitle indonesia
  • canon pixma ip1800 printer software
  • google map pocket pc free
  • malayalam mobile movie free site
  • nokia pc free download latest version
  • third age total war mod 2.0
  • the avengers movie full download in hindi hd
  • fast life joe jonas download mp3
  • fairy tail season 1 full
  • holograf ochii tai free
  • fazer download de photoshop gratis
  • diablo 2 download free full game
  • mba cet test papers free
  • quarteto fantastico avi legendado
  • florin salam mare sukarime live zippy
  • ressaca de amor download dublado
  • download buku elektronik sma gratis
  • oficina g3 ddg experience cd
  • cisco cucm 8.6 ova download
  • live tv application for android
  • windows xp professional chomikuj
  • x men 3 mp4 download
  • territory war hacked
  • iphone 4 ios 6 iclarified
  • download do filme enrolados rmvb dublado dvdrip
  • jogos de gta gratis para pc
  • turn it up busta rhymes mp3
  • whatsapp pc windows 7
  • pagina inicial do google para baixar