«
»

Clarification: What sucks and what don’t

04.23.05 | 4 Comments

ono.gifSean of Ministrare is right.  Something is happening in UU circles.  I don’t want to overplay it, but the UU blogosphere abounds in discussions of what our "unity amid diversity" might be.  (See Chalice Chick’s review for links.) The new UU Theology listserv is aimed directly at the issue.  And Sean reports movements along the same in the UU bureaucracy.

The natural starting points for this discussion are UUism’s "Purposes & Principles."   Chalice Chick points out that I’m arguing that—contrary to the usual quips—the P&P don’t suck.  Sean points out that that I’m only "timidly defending" the P&P.  So what exactly am I saying?

1) Let’s start with what I’m not saying.   I’m not saying the P&P are "pie in the sky by and by."  Their lack of poetry reveals their bureaucratic origin, and I am naturally predisposed to dismiss anything that comes from a bureaucracy.  (Trying to put that as politely as I can.)  They can be improved, and they should be periodically.

I’m also not saying they should function as a creed (more on that below).  Not even that they are good enough to do so if we wished.  So set your panic buttons to off.

2)  Now to what I am saying.   

In spite of their bureaucratic origins, the P&P still contain some genuine theological poetry.  Not a lot, but enough to warrant some respect.  I attribute this happy coincidence (of poetry with bureaucracy) to grace.  Why?

At UUCA we have a growing group for twenty- and thirtysomethings.  Almost everyone in this loose knit group of 100+ folks is new to UUism.  Most are single, although there is a sizable minority of married/partnered folks, some with young children.

I have been amazed that a good number (eight or twelve) of the forty or fifty folks in the group who I’ve met have said that reading the P&P (online, usually) was central to their decision to come and get involved.  The proportion was similar in my new member class five years ago.  Don’t look that gift horse in the mouth. 

This was my experience too.  The P&P told me that UUs weren’t the "knock on the door with nothing to say," nor were UUs putting on a circle jerk to worn photos of Carl Sagan, Carl Rogers, and Bertrand Russell.   I saw enough of that in high school, thanks.  I saw something in the P&P that spoke to a larger vision.

Why then are the P&P so maligned?  First, because of an irrational fear of creeds (almost to that below).  Second, because familiarity breeds contempt. 

Third, because so many UUs seem to think that every [good American, rational person, etc.] already agrees with the P&P.  If you think that, I challenge you to ask the next ten nonUUs you meet outside of Harvard Square if the P&P describe what they believe.  More will say no than yes.  Otherwise, things like this wouldn’t be happening at such an increasing frequency.

3)  Finally, some things I haven’t said before/yet.  Our "creed phobia" has to stop.  I fully realize and appreciate that there are good historical reasons we do not have a creed.  I don’t want a "creed" myself.

But as Paul Wilczynski points out, the P&P practically function as a creed.   Yet many of us (myself, sometimes) exhibit what looks to me like terror at the thought.  That can’t be healthy, and it can’t help but send a crazy message to others. Especially to would-be UUs, or at least the ones who don’t share that terror.  (And my experience teaches me that pre-terrified proto-UUs are the vast minority.") "Creed terror" does’t have anything to do with those good historical reasons for not having a creed, because if it did it wouldn’t exhibit as terror.  I won’t venture to say what’s causing this creed terror, but I’ll suggest the cure lies in spending some time in what my Pentecostal neighbor would call your "personal prayer closet."

Those folks at UUCA who came because of the P&P weren’t looking for a "creed," by the way.  They weren’t looking for someone to tell them what they should believe, so you can put that insulting diatribe aside now.  They wondered what we stood for, and the P&P gave them a good idea. 

Is that wrong?  Is that harmful in any way?  Is there any justification for chastising them as "ye of little faith" because they found the P&P helpful, or even comforting? 

I challenge anyone who feels otherwise to answer me with a non-elitist argument that honors the experience of our fellow UUs who have experienced some small measure of grace throught the P&P.  I’m all for calling them the "Seven Dwarves," and I too wonder "where’s the beef?"  But they are still a gift of grace to UUism, and that’s nothing to balk at.

4 Comments

have your say

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. Subscribe to these comments.

Be colorful. Keep it fun. Stay on topic. No spam.

:  (required)

:  (required, not published)

 (wow! a link to my site!)


«
»
  • basi karaoke originali download
  • alma encantadora das ruas download gorden
  • career planning ppt download
  • blue night turn me loose download
  • a quarta dimensA?o download liberte
  • bible audiobook download mp3
  • aplicatii iphone 2g download
  • apprentice los angeles download full version
  • bruxa de blair download avi legendado
  • bedava n73 temalarA download
  • burlesque download legendado rmvb
  • besplatan download domaAe glazbe
  • blown away mp3 download carrie
  • chandelier bob free mp3 download
  • beto guedes cd download
  • bhor bhaye panghat song download
  • ben saunders download mp3 free
  • chopin etudes download mp3
  • ambiente runtime java download
  • ben howard gracious free download
  • bartpe norton ghost download
  • blunt cruisin asher roth download
  • as grandes equaAAes livro download
  • astral projection mahadeva download
  • adriano celentano greatest hits download
  • aleksandra radovic u inat download
  • bard's tale pc game download
  • blue progress bar download
  • cancion de colores download
  • behringer ddm 4000 driver download
  • aranmanai kili mp3 download
  • canon pixma mp510 manual download
  • 4shared download adele set fire to the rain
  • business plan project download
  • adobe weiss font download
  • chicony dc 2112 driver download
  • beyblade v force music download
  • 11th hour download mac
  • 7 zip download for win7 64bit
  • banjo kazooie game download pc
  • chupke chupke ghulam ali download
  • arde parazitii download zippy
  • 20 va satabdam video songs download
  • cd oklahoma 2011 download
  • appreciation letter format download
  • banno rani song free download
  • acer aspire 3630 treiber download
  • a7x lbc download dvd
  • abre los ojos bso download
  • bleach 347 download sub ita
  • achtung baby at twenty download
  • cd dj alpiste 2011 download
  • calcolo del codice fiscale download gratis
  • base de dados empresas download
  • club dj software download
  • chalk talk on alcoholism download
  • ati x1600 driver download windows 7
  • allods online patch 1.1.04 download
  • blackmagic disk speed test 2.1 download
  • amd sempron 2600 download driver
  • boks gry pc download
  • bulb into the deep download
  • christmas carols free download boney m
  • benq dvd rom 16x driver download
  • a4tech model pk 635m driver free download
  • beogradski sindikat pazi pazi download mp3
  • booker t theme download free
  • bypass metin2 ro download
  • babbal rai songs download free
  • alley cat song download