It is difficult for this Oklahoma City native to swallow September 11 exceptionalism. September 11 is a tragedy, but it is a tragedy proportionate to April 19. The differences in scope, method, and impact are proportionate to the differences between New York City’s and Oklahoma City’s size, scope and impact. One a geopolitical scale, one outscales the other. On a personal scale, the effect was too much the same.
Two September 11s ago, as my wife and I went out to celebrate her birthday, I couldn’t help but feel that I was watching a rerun, a sequel. It was not the first large scale terrorist attack on the US, and it was no more a declaration of war than April 19. But where the US met April 19 with grief, incomprehension, and resolution, it met September 11 with grief, incomprehension, and undirected vengeance. Oklahoma City has largely healed from April 19. I don’t see that America wants to heal from the wounds of September 11. Mostly, it seems, it wants to be shocked.
I’m skipping the media re-orgy today. I learned to do that seven years ago, when the first April 19 re-orgy debuted. When you lived through it you don’t need a reminder. Instead of dreading the memories–which don’t need so much as an anniversary to pop up–you dread the media. The photos and sound are too much. The media-added melodrama is a second violence, a terrorism upon the soul. I still say Connie Chung can go to hell for scolding the Oklahoma City Fire Department for not being ready for a terrorist attack. When an event leaves even search dogs depressed, there is little that could have been done.
There will be dozens of retrospectives today, dozens of “what was it like?” and “where are we now?” Whistling in the dark. And in the end, spitting into the wind. Evil doesn’t retreat from mere rehearsals of evil deads. It feeds off it.
We must find some way to weave April 19 and September 11 into the fabric of what it means to be an American. We must own up to the evil we suffered but also own up to the evil we have caused. Detractors can accuse those of us calling for reflection and introspection of America hating, but we have good company. But perhaps the call to embrace your enemy does not apply to America. Perhaps Jesus meant to say “but unless, of course, you are sure you are right.” And, of course, America has always been right.
As long as we’re talking about soul, mine is worth £15855, which means that 46% of people have a purer soul than me. Any takers? (Hat tip to Anastasia.)
As I sit in a new therapist’s waiting room for the third time in my life, I notice I’ve been thinking a lot about choices lately, and the absence of them. And I suspect the situation got screwed up sometime during the Axial Age (some two thousand years ago).
Saul/Paul’s gift to the world was the soul divided against itself. If you ever find yourself deeply at odds with yourself, you have the Apostle Paul to thank. Before him, no one really wrote about it that much. For Paul, it is key to everything.
But “at odds with yourself” doesn’t quite describe it. For Paul –and for countless Christian writers after him– to be a person at all is to be deeply divided between sin and grace, between flesh and spirit. Augustine added the mythology of Original Sin to the mix, and untold gallons of ink have been spilled since trying to balance out the equation, sin and death and the flesh versus grace and the spirit and peace. Paul thought that the mind is stuck with making the choice, so perhaps it’s little wonder. But in the end, Paul gives no peace, only the knowledge that we are obligated to do what we cannot do.
Click to continue reading “For what I want to do I do not do”
From Real Live Preacher:
A woman in the movie told a classic Jewish joke. It seems a Jewish man was stranded on an island for many years. His rescuers found that he had built two synagogues on the island. They asked him why he had two, and he said, “One to pray in and the other not to step foot in for the rest of my life, so help me GOD.”
I absolutely understand that joke.
I am an unbeliever at heart, you see. I can’t help myself. Perhaps I’m not wired for belief, or maybe my wires are crossed. I just cannot bring myself to believe what I cannot see. This is who I am.
I hate middle aged white women who need provolone cheese.
A friend tells me of a summer job in a deli that several middle aged white women would come into the store. They were quite picky about their sandwiches, even when they didn’t realize what they wanted until after it was ordered and half made. In one memorable instance, this equated to a need for provolone cheese.
Middle aged white women who need provolone cheese should not be allowed to sit on church committees. They should not try to act like they’re the chair when they’re not. They should not talk more than all other committee members combined. When the committee finishes its work early, they should not view it as an opportunity to spend half an hour hashing out details that will take care of themselves. They should not read committee minutes to themselves out loud during the meeting. They should not bring up old, settled business as though it was new business that only they had the intelligence to think of.
I hate middle aged white women who need provolone cheese.